Pathogenetic Justification of the Role of Cognitive Filters in the Functioning of Systemic Adaptation under Stress-Induced Disorders


Cite item

Abstract

 Traditional models of stress (H. Selye) primarily emphasize humoral mechanisms (sympatho-adrenal system, cortisol-related) and psychosocial mechanisms (anxiety, resistance, exhaustion). However, this does not resolve the open question of individual resilience: why, under identical conditions (exogenous factors), some individuals develop pathological systems (ICD-10 rubric F), while others do not. From the standpoint of contemporary psychiatric doctrine, the decisive factor is “critical thinking.” The aim. To substantiate the role of cognitive filters as a key pathogenetic link and protective mechanism of the central nervous system, preventing the transition of functional stress reactions into pathological states. Materials and Methods. The study was conducted in the format of a theoretical-analytical investigation employing conceptual modeling. A systematic review of 20 scientific sources (coverage period: 1956–2024) was performed, selected from PubMed, Scopus, Google Scholar, and eLIBRARY.ru. Comparative analysis was applied to classical stress models (H. Selye), the theory of functional systems (P.K. Anokhin), and modern concepts of psychosocial adaptation. Results. It was established that cognitive filters operate at the stage of afferent synthesis, enabling modification of stressor significance and adjustment of the predictive model within the action result acceptor. At the micro-level of adaptation, they serve as instruments for revising the “Bayesian cognitive model,” thereby reducing the risk of neurogenic toxicity and structural brain changes (dendritic atrophy, amygdala hypertrophy). It was demonstrated that the effective functioning of these filters is a necessary condition for the realization of psychosocial adaptation as one of the fundamental indicators of health. Conclusion. Cognitive filters represent an active component of systemic adaptation, determining individual resilience to stress. Their integration into the general scheme of the pathogenesis of stress-induced disorders allows the training of mechanisms of critical reappraisal to be considered a promising direction in the prevention and therapy of mental and psychosomatic disorders.

Full Text

Introduction. Stress remains one of the central challenges in contemporary medicine and psychology. Hans Selye’s classical model describes the general adaptation syndrome as a sequence of stages—alarm, resistance, and exhaustion—emphasizing humoral mechanisms through activation of the sympatho-adrenal and hypothalamic–pituitary–adrenal (HPA) systems [1]. However, this model does not fully resolve the question of individual resilience: why, under comparable exogenous stressors, do some individuals develop clinically significant disorders (F43.2, F32–F33, F41 according to ICD-10), whereas others maintain psychological stability or even demonstrate adaptive growth?

Addressing this question requires a transition from a purely physiological framework to an integrative model that considers the central nervous system as an active regulator of adaptation. P.K. Anokhin’s theory of functional systems [2] conceptualizes adaptation as goal-directed activity, in which afferent synthesis—integrating motivation, memory, current afferentation, and feedback—plays a pivotal role. Within this framework, higher cognitive processes may intervene at critical stages, modifying the functional system and preventing the consolidation of maladaptive responses.

In this study, we propose that cognitive filters (mechanisms of critical reappraisal) represent active components of systemic adaptation that reduce the likelihood of progression from functional disturbances to persistent pathological states. These mechanisms may prevent the transition described by I.P. Pavlov as a “breakdown” of higher nervous activity, a process in which prolonged functional dysregulation may contribute to subsequent structural and neurobiological alterations [6]. This conceptual approach complements traditional stress models and aligns with contemporary theoretical frameworks, including the concept of allostasis and allostatic load [5], as well as computational psychiatry models based on the Bayesian brain hypothesis [4]. Additionally, it corresponds to modern integrative biomedical concepts defining psychosocial adaptation as a critical determinant of health [3].

Selye introduced the concept of the general adaptation syndrome, in which a stressor elicits a nonspecific physiological response aimed at restoring homeostasis. Later developments expanded this view through the concepts of allostasis and allostatic load [5], proposing that the organism does not merely maintain fixed homeostasis but actively anticipates change through adaptive regulation. Chronic activation of these mechanisms, however, leads to cumulative physiological burden, which manifests in somatic (cardiovascular, immune, endocrine) and psychiatric disorders.

Nevertheless, Selye’s model remains insufficient in explaining individual differences. Even under comparable stressors (such as war, pandemics, or prolonged social instability), some individuals develop severe depressive, anxiety, or psychosomatic disorders, while others exhibit resilience.

In contrast, Anokhin’s model explains adaptation as a functional system organized around key nodes [2]:

  • Afferent synthesis: integration of dominant motivation, memory, triggering afferentation, and feedback afferentation;
  • Decision-making: selection of an action program;
  • Acceptor of action results: a predictive model of the expected outcome, continuously compared with actual feedback.

Under conditions of stress, a dominant pattern of threat avoidance may emerge. If the acceptor of action results forms a pessimistic predictive model (e.g., “danger is unavoidable” or “the situation is uncontrollable”), the system may consolidate into a maladaptive configuration. Cognitive filters may interrupt this cycle by modifying stimulus significance at the stage of afferent synthesis or by updating predictive modeling at the level of the acceptor, thereby weakening the pathological dominant focus.

From this perspective, Pavlov’s “breakdown” of higher nervous activity can be described as a continuum: from reversible functional shifts (changes in neural firing patterns and regulatory balance) to longer-term neurobiological alterations. Contemporary data indicate that this transition is associated with chronic hyperactivation of the HPA axis, including:

  • sustained cortisol elevation → glutamatergic excitotoxicity → reduction of neurotrophic support → suppression of hippocampal neurogenesis;
  • dendritic atrophy in the prefrontal cortex;
  • hypertrophy and hyperreactivity of the basolateral amygdala [7].

Cognitive reappraisal mechanisms may counteract these processes by reducing emotional salience of stressors and decreasing amygdala-driven threat signaling.

Aim. To demonstrate cognitive filters as a key protective mechanism of the CNS that may prevent the development of pathological stress reactions.

Materials and Methods. This work represents a theoretical-analytical study combining elements of systematic literature review and conceptual modeling. The study included:

  • Systematic review: Stepwise analysis of literature using a PRISMA-like approach (identification, screening, selection, synthesis). For each source, key concepts, strengths/limitations, and integration points were identified.
  • Comparative analysis: Juxtaposition of models by definition, role in stress response, level of analysis, and practical significance.

Sources were selected based on relevance, timeliness, and scientific reliability:

  • Databases: PubMed, Google Scholar, Scopus, Web of Science, and Russian-language resources (eLIBRARY.ru, CyberLeninka) for seminal works of Anokhin and Pavlov.
  • Time frame: 1956 (Selye) to 2024 (López-Otín & Kroemer), with emphasis on post-2000 publications.
  • Types: Monographs, peer-reviewed articles, meta-analyses, reviews (n=11 key references).
  • Keywords: “cognitive filters,” “stress adaptation,” “functional systems theory,” “allostatic load,” “psychosocial adaptation,” “Bayesian brain,” “cognitive reappraisal.”
  • Exclusions: Popular literature, non-peer-reviewed sources, works lacking empirical or theoretical basis.
  • Scope: ~20 sources analyzed, 11 directly cited.

Results. Critical reappraisal represents successful updating of the Bayesian cognitive model, reducing pathological expectations and enhancing adaptive ones. In 2024, López-Otín and Kroemer proposed psychosocial adaptation as the ninth hallmark of health, complementing spatial compartmentalization, temporal homeostasis, and adequate stress responses. These hallmarks span all eight somatic levels of the human organism (molecules, organelles, cells, multicellular units, organs, organ systems, systemic neural networks, and organismal systems) [3].

Cognitive filters operate at the micro-level of psychosocial adaptation, shaping individual interpretation of social stressors (Anokhin–Pavlov models). Psychosocial adaptation functions at the macro-level, encompassing support, culture, and social status (Selye–López models). A comparative summary is presented in Table 1.

Aspect

Cognitive Filters

Psychosocial Adaptation

Definition

Mental mechanisms of selection, interpretation, and processing of information that influence the organism’s response to stress.

The ability of individuals and society to adapt to psychosocial challenges while maintaining health and resilience.

Role in Stress Response

Determine which stimuli are perceived as threats and which as neutral; form the pathogenetic basis of stress-induced disorders.

Provide balance between internal resources and external demands, reducing the risk of chronic stress and psychosomatic disorders.

Level of Analysis

Individual neuropsychological level (cognitive processes, neural networks).

Systemic and interdisciplinary level (biology, psychology, social factors).

Practical Significance

Enable understanding of mechanisms underlying anxiety and depressive disorders and inform the development of cognitive-behavioral interventions.

Highlight the necessity of incorporating social and cultural factors into medical strategies for prevention and therapy.

Interrelation

Cognitive filters represent the “micro-level” of adaptation, explaining how stress is processed within the psyche.

Psychosocial adaptation represents the “macro-level,” demonstrating how individuals are embedded in social systems and receive support.

 

Figure 1. Comparative table of stress-adaptation concepts: Anokhin–Pavlov framework (micro-level of neurophysiological regulation) versus Selye–López-Otín & Kroemer framework (macro-level of systemic stress response and psychosocial adaptation).

Conclusion. The pathogenetic rationale for cognitive filters complements the López-Otín & Kroemer framework: cognitive filters can be regarded as internal mechanisms of psychosocial adaptation, determining how effectively individuals cope with stress. Thus, cognitive filters represent “tools” of adaptation at the psychological level, while psychosocial adaptation constitutes a broader “hallmark of health,” encompassing social ties, cultural contexts, and support systems. In the era of chronic stress (pandemics, wars, social crises), training these filters through cognitive-behavioral approaches may become a key strategy for prevention and therapy of stress-induced disorders.

×

About the authors

Ilya Zaikov

I.K. Akchunbaev Kyrgyz State Medical Academy

Author for correspondence.
Email: zajkovila88@gmail.com
ORCID iD: 0009-0004-0800-9285
SPIN-code: 6874-7508

3rd-year student, Faculty of General Medicine.

Kyrgyzstan, 720020, Kyrgyzstan, Bishkek, I. Akhunbaev Street, 92

Altynai A. Kazieva


I.K. Akchunbaev Kyrgyz State Medical Academy

Email: altynai-kazieva@mail.ru

Candidate of Medical Sciences, Associate Professor, Department of Pathophysiology

Kyrgyzstan, 720020, Kyrgyzstan, Bishkek, I. Akhunbaev Street, 92

References

  1. Selye H. The stress of life. New York: McGraw-Hill; 1956.
  2. Анохин П.К. Биология и нейрофизиология условного рефлекса. М.: Медицина; 1968.
  3. López-Otín C, Kroemer G. The missing hallmark of health: psychosocial adaptation. Cell Stress. 2024;8(1):21-50. doi: 10.15698/cst2024.03.294
  4. Stephan KE, et al. Charting the landscape of priority problems in psychiatry, part 2: pathogenesis and aetiology. Lancet Psychiatry. 2016;3(1):84-90. doi: 10.1016/S2215-0366(15)00360-0
  5. McEwen BS. Allostasis and allostatic load: implications for neuropsychopharmacology. Neuropsychopharmacology. 2000;22(2):108-24.
  6. Павлов И.П. Лекции о работе больших полушарий головного мозга. М.-Л.: Медгиз; 1949.
  7. McEwen BS, et al. Stress effects on neuronal structure: hippocampus, amygdala, and prefrontal cortex. Neuropsychopharmacology. 2016;41(1):3-23.

Supplementary files

There are no supplementary files to display.

This website uses cookies

You consent to our cookies if you continue to use our website.

About Cookies